It is understandable why so many people—especially young women—feel deeply alienated when they encounter churches that restrict women from serving as trustees, elders, or preachers. To many outside (and inside) the faith, restricting leadership by gender feels out of step with fairness and basic respect.
So why do some churches do this — and other conservative evangelical bodies aligned with movements like GAFCON—hold to this position?
Understanding the Conservative Stance: “Complementarianism”
Churches that restrict women from governance or authoritative teaching generally describe their view as complementarian. The core argument is not that women are inferior to men in value, intelligence, or spiritual gifts. Rather, they believe God created men and women equal in worth, but with distinct, non-interchangeable roles in the family and the church.
Their primary arguments rest on a few specific passages:
- 1 Timothy 2:12 & Titus 1: Verses where Paul states, “I do not permit a woman to teach or to assume authority over a man,” alongside guidelines requiring church elders/overseers to be men.
- Male Headship: A theological belief that ultimate authority and responsibility in the local church rest with qualified male elders, which is why positions like senior pastor, preacher, or trustee are reserved for men.
While those who hold this position see it as faithful obedience to Scripture, it raises significant questions when weighed against the rest of the New Testament.
Pivoting the View: Why Scripture Supports Women in Leadership
Looking at the broader narrative of the Bible, there is a compelling case that God calls and equips both men and women for every level of ministry.
1. Spiritual Gifts Are Not Gender-Restricted
In Ephesians 4:11–12, Paul lists the ministry gifts given to equip God’s people:
“So Christ himself gave the apostles, the prophets, the evangelists, the pastors and teachers, to equip his people for works of service…”
Notice what is missing from this passage: any mention of gender. Paul does not say apostles or pastors are exclusively men. Spiritual gifts are distributed by the Holy Spirit as He chooses, given to women and men alike for building up the church.
2. Cultural Context vs. Universal Rules
One of the most cited verses against women speaking in church is 1 Corinthians 14:34–35 (“Women should remain silent in the churches”). However, taking this as an absolute, timeless command creates obvious contradictions—even within the same letter.
In 1 Corinthians 11, Paul explicitly gives instructions on how women should pray and prophesy during public worship, which proves they were speaking publicly. The command in chapter 14 was contextual, addressed to a specific culture where women—who lacked formal education—were shouting out questions or chatting from separate gallery areas during orderly worship, causing disruption in the assembly.
3. The Radial Example of Jesus
If you examine how Jesus treated women, He consistently broke the social and religious taboos of His era to elevate and empower them:
- The First Evangelist to Samaria: In John 4, Jesus reveals His identity as the Messiah to the Samaritan woman at the well. She immediately becomes an evangelist, bringing her entire town to meet Him.
- Sitting at the Teacher’s Feet: In Luke 10:38–42, Mary of Bethany sits at Jesus’ feet to learn. In first-century Judaism, sitting at a rabbi’s feet was the formal posture of a disciple training to become a teacher—a role reserved strictly for men. Jesus defends her right to be there.
- Financial and Practical Leadership: Luke 8:1–3 records that Jesus’ ministry was backed and supported by prominent women—including Mary Magdalene, Joanna, and Susanna—who used their own resources to care for the disciples.
- The First Witnesses of the Resurrection: In all four Gospels, women (led by Mary Magdalene) are the very first people to witness the risen Christ. In a culture where a woman’s legal testimony was not even accepted in court, Jesus specifically commissioned women to go and preach the Gospel of the Resurrection to the male apostles.
4. Women Leaders in the Early Church
Beyond the Gospels, the early apostolic church relied heavily on women in key leadership roles:
- Phoebe (Romans 16:1–2): A deacon of the church in Cenchrea and a patron of many, trusted by Paul to deliver his letter to Rome.
- Priscilla (Acts 18:26): Alongside her husband Aquila, she took the eloquent preacher Apollos aside and explained the way of God to him more accurately.
- Junia (Romans 16:7): Explicitly commended by Paul as “outstanding among the apostles.”
- Lydia (Acts 16): A successful businesswoman who hosted and led the first house church in Europe.
Conclusion
The stance that excludes women from trusteeship or preaching relies on isolating a few cultural instructions while overlooking the overarching pattern of Jesus’ ministry and the early church.
Jesus entrusted His most important news to women. The Holy Spirit pours out gifts without gender restrictions. When churches restrict women from exercising their God-given gifts today, they miss out on the full breadth of leadership God intended for His church.


Leave a Reply