Father Christmas in Green

Sowing Seeds of Hope | Youth Work & Faith in Cornwall

Cultivating Purpose, Community, and Faith on the Cornish Coast

Naughty, Nice, or Just Human?

The Tale of Two Christmas Figures

“Every December, we get told the exact same thing: You’d better watch out, you’d better not cry, you’d better not pout… because someone is making a list, checking it twice, and categorising every single person in this room into one of two boxes: Good or Bad.”

In traditional European street parades Santa Claus along with other characters (figures like Krampus, or Belsnickel), are the dark, ragged figures who walk at the very front. Their job was to rattle chains, carry switches, and hunt down anyone who hadn’t behaved, threatening to toss them into a sack.

Right at the tail end of the parade comes Father Christmas—the jolly figure in green or red, laughing, handing out sweets, bringing light, food, and gifts to celebrate getting through the darkest winter days.

Are you naughty or Nice?

I need 3 volunteers. I’m going to read three everyday situations. You have three choices: A, B, or C. I need you to call out your choice.

The Last Custard Cream

You walk into the kitchen or common room. There is exactly one biscuit left on the plate. It is a chocolate bourbon or a custard cream, and you know someone else had their eye on it.

  • A (Saintly): Snap it in half, offer the bigger piece to the other person, and say, “After you.”
  • B (Pragmatic/In-Between): Eat it immediately in one bite so no one can argue, but throw away the wrapper so there’s no evidence.
  • C (Pure Chaos): Lick the biscuit, put it back on the plate, make direct eye contact, and walk out.

The Group Chat Disaster

A controversial photo or massive rumour drops into the year-group group chat at 9:30 PM. It’s obviously going to cause huge drama by tutor tomorrow morning.

  • A (Saintly): Post “Guys, delete this, it’s out of order,” and message the person affected to make sure they’re alright.
  • B (Pragmatic/In-Between): Put your phone on ‘Do Not Disturb’, mute the chat for eight hours, and go to sleep. Not your circus, not your monkeys.
  • C (Pure Chaos): Drop the popcorn emoji, screenshot it before anyone can delete it, and forward it to three other group chats with the caption “It’s kicking off.”

The Dropped Fiver

You’re walking down the high street or corridor, and a fiver falls out of someone’s pocket right in front of you. They haven’t noticed.

  • A (Saintly): Jog up immediately, tap their shoulder: “Excuse me, you dropped this!”
  • B (Pragmatic/In-Between): Step on it, wait till they turn the corner, pick it up, and tell yourself: “If they’re rich enough to drop a fiver without noticing, they won’t miss a hot pasty at lunch.”
  • C (Pure Chaos): Pick it up, jog up to them, and say, “Thanks for the donation, mate,” before walking into the nearest shop.

The Reveal

Were you mostly A’s, B’s or C’s?

  • Mostly A’s:“Father Christmas’s star student. Probably never had a detention, washes up without being asked, possibly suspicious.”
  • Mostly B’s:“The Survivors. You aren’t evil, but you’re definitely looking out for number one. You’ll make it to the end of term intact.”
  • Mostly C’s:“The Front of the Parade. If Santa Claus comes down your road, he’s not even bringing a sack—he’s recruiting you.”

Wrap Up

We joke about being ‘naughty’ or ‘good’, and songs make it sound like you’re either 100% angelic or entirely on the naughty step. But in real life, none of us fit neatly into those boxes. We all have days where we’re patient and generous (Option A), days where we just want to keep our heads down and survive (Option B), and days where we make a mess of things, lose our temper, or act a bit selfish (Option C).

The real reason Father Christmas stays at the back of the parade—bringing presents, warmth, and light—isn’t because everyone proved they were flawless all year. It’s because winter is tough, life is hard work, and everyone needs a bit of goodwill and a second chance.

As we head into the holidays, you don’t have to be perfect. Just try, whenever you have the choice, not to leave a mess for someone else to clean up, check in on your mates, and bring a bit of Father Christmas energy rather than parade-monster energy into your home.”


Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *