Wuthering Heights picture guide

Sowing Seeds of Hope | Youth Work & Faith in Cornwall

Cultivating Purpose, Community, and Faith on the Cornish Coast

The “Real” Wuthering Heights: Why the Film is Only Half the Story

Why why why? It is a classic. It can’t be improved and yet some director thinks they know better. Seriously this book has stood the test of time and has only improved. Why do you take all the grittiness out of it and substitute it for sex? As you will see later in this post, for me the book is a story about revenge, family cycles, and whether we can ever truly escape our upbringing. It is perfect for today’s young people. It challenges social norms and offers a tale in two halves. There is a reason this book has been a “must-read” for nearly 200 years, and it isn’t just because of the drama.

The Intro: Why the Film Gets it Wrong

You might have seen the trailers for the new Wuthering Heights and thought it looked like another typical, high-drama romance full of ‘aesthetic’ vibes and toxic relationships. But here’s the truth: the film basically hits ‘delete’ on the most important part of the story. While the movie focuses on the messy, destructive love between the original Cathy and Heathcliff, the book is actually a much bigger story about family curses and how to break them.

The Author: Who was “Ellis Bell”?

The book was published in 1847 by Emily Brontë, but you wouldn’t have seen her name on the cover. She used the pseudonym (a fake name) Ellis Bell.

At the time, the literary world was very much a “boys’ club.” Female authors were often dismissed or expected to write “soft” stories about tea parties and manners. Emily and her sisters (Charlotte and Anne) chose names that sounded male so their work would be judged on its own merits. Wuthering Heights was so wild and violent that many critics at the time were horrified—they certainly didn’t think a “lady” could (or should) write something so raw.

The Plot: A Tale of Two Houses

The story is set in the rugged, windy hills of Yorkshire (think of the wilder parts of Cornwall, but colder!). It follows two main families: the Earnshaws at Wuthering Heights and the Lintons at Thrushcross Grange.

The Family Tree: Who is Who?

The book can be confusing because the names repeat! Here is a quick guide to the two houses and how they eventually merge:

The Earnshaws (Wuthering Heights)

  • Mr. Earnshaw: The father who brings home the orphan, Heathcliff.
  • Hindley: The son who hates Heathcliff and bullies him.
  • Catherine (The Elder): The daughter who falls for Heathcliff but chooses status instead.
  • Hareton: Hindley’s son. Heathcliff tries to ruin him by keeping him uneducated, but Hareton has a heart of gold.

The Lintons (Thrushcross Grange)

  • Edgar Linton: The wealthy, refined man who marries the elder Catherine.
  • Isabella: Edgar’s sister, who unfortunately marries Heathcliff and suffers for it.
  • Catherine (The Younger): Edgar and Catherine’s daughter. She is the hero of the second half of the book.
  • Linton Heathcliff: The son of Heathcliff and Isabella. He is sickly and used as a pawn by his father.

The Revenge

Heartbroken and angry, Heathcliff disappears and returns years later as a wealthy man. He spends the rest of his life trying to destroy both families as revenge for his childhood.

The Ending the Film Missed

Most adaptations focus only on the toxic “love” between the original Cathy and Heathcliff. But the book is actually in two halves. In the book’s conclusion, it’s Cathy’s daughter, Catherine Linton, and Hareton Earnshaw, the nephew Heathcliff tried to turn into a brute that get married.

Why this matters:

  1. Breaking the Cycle: Heathcliff spent his life trying to degrade Hareton to get revenge on Hareton’s father. But young Catherine teaches Hareton to read. They fall in love through kindness and education—the exact opposite of the violence and ego that destroyed the older generation.
  2. Redemption: Their upcoming marriage on New Year’s Day symbolises a fresh start. It shows that while the parents chose revenge, the children chose forgiveness.
  3. Peace: It’s only when this young couple finds happiness that Heathcliff finally loses his will to fight and dies, supposedly reuniting with the original Cathy in the afterlife.

Without this ending, the story is just a “misery-fest.” The second generation provides the hope that we don’t have to be defined by our parents’ mistakes.

A Footnote: Victorian Terms for Modern Readers

If you decide to pick up the actual book, here are a few words that might trip you up:

  • Pseudonym: A fictitious name used by an author to conceal their identity.
  • The Moors: Wide, open areas of high land, often covered in heather and very windy (the “vibe” of the book).
  • Wuthering: A local word describing the sound of the wind blowing hard around a building.
  • Grange: A country house with farm buildings (Thrushcross Grange is the “fancy” house in the story).
  • Calamity: An event causing great and often sudden damage or distress; a disaster.
  • Degenerate: To decline or deteriorate physically, mentally, or morally.

What was she trying to achieve?

Emily Bronte wasn’t trying to write a “happily ever after.” She wanted to explore the raw power of nature versus the constraints of “civilised” society. She wanted to show how hate can be passed down like an inheritance, and how only a specific kind of love can break that cycle. The film has completely missed Emily’s original intent. What a shame.

Wuthering Heights picture guide
Wuthering Heights picture guide

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *